The Trump Classified Documents Indictment, Annotated - The World News

The Trump Classified Documents Indictment, Annotated


The Justice Department on Friday unveiled an indictment charging former President Donald J. Trump with 37 criminal counts. They relate to Mr. Trump’s hoarding of sensitive government documents after he left office and his refusal to return them, even after being subpoenaed for all remaining records in his possession that were marked as classified.




31 counts

Related to withholding national defense information

One count against Mr. Trump for each document he was alleged to have kept in his possession.

5 counts

Related to concealing possession of classified documents

Among them are counts of conspiracy to obstruct justice and withholding documents and records, levied against both Mr. Trump and an aide, Walt Nauta.

2 counts

False statements

Related to statements to the F.B.I. by Mr. Trump and an aide, Walt Nauta.


49 pages

A list of charges against Donald Trump.





The New York Times annotated the indictment.


Download the original PDF.

Page 1 of Trump Documents Indictment Color PDF document.

New York Times Analysis


Next »

1
Although law enforcement officials conducted most of the investigation using a grand jury in Washington, the special counsel chose to bring the case in Florida. That avoided a potential legal fight over venue, but it carried the risk that the case would be assigned to Judge Aileen M. Cannon, who was appointed by former President Donald J. Trump and who has issued a series of rulings unusually favorable to him. Judge Cannon will indeed take the case, according to people familiar with the matter.

Page 2 of Trump Documents Indictment Color PDF document.

New York Times Analysis

« Previous
Next »

2
The indictment lays out the potential danger of the classified information in the documents Mr. Trump kept at his Mar-a-Lago estate.

Page 3 of Trump Documents Indictment Color PDF document.

New York Times Analysis

« Previous
Next »

3
As has been recently reported, the special counsel, Jack Smith, has apparently obtained an audio recording of Mr. Trump acknowledging that he knew a document in his possession was still classified. That stands at odds with Mr. Trump’s public claims that he had declassified all the materials he took from the Oval Office. (No credible evidence has emerged to support that claim, which his lawyers had declined to repeat in court, where there are professional consequences for lying.)

4
This section of the indictment outlines another incident in which Mr. Trump is accused of having shown a classified document to someone while acknowledging that it was still secret. It does not refer to a recording, raising the possibility that the unidentified representative of his political action committee provided this account to investigators.

5
The indictment lays out five specific actions by Mr. Trump that it says were illegal obstruction.

Page 4 of Trump Documents Indictment Color PDF document.

New York Times Analysis

« Previous
Next »

6
Mr. Trump’s aide Walt Nauta was also indicted and is described in this filing as a co-conspirator in the crimes.

Page 5 of Trump Documents Indictment Color PDF document.

New York Times Analysis

« Previous
Next »

7
The indictment emphasizes how many people were wandering in and out of Mr. Trump’s estate in Florida, implying that improperly storing classified documents there risked their disclosure.

Page 6 of Trump Documents Indictment Color PDF document.

Page 7 of Trump Documents Indictment Color PDF document.

Page 8 of Trump Documents Indictment Color PDF document.

Page 9 of Trump Documents Indictment Color PDF document.

New York Times Analysis

« Previous
Next »

8
The indictment uses Mr. Trump’s words from the 2016 campaign, attacking his rival, Hillary Clinton, over her use of a private email server while she was secretary of state, to show he understood the importance of protecting classified information.

Page 10 of Trump Documents Indictment Color PDF document.

New York Times Analysis

« Previous
Next »

9
The indictment includes a photograph showing that some of the boxes Mr. Trump had taken from the White House were stored for a time in a ballroom in Mar-a-Lago where guests had access.

Page 11 of Trump Documents Indictment Color PDF document.

Page 12 of Trump Documents Indictment Color PDF document.

Page 13 of Trump Documents Indictment Color PDF document.

Page 14 of Trump Documents Indictment Color PDF document.

New York Times Analysis

« Previous
Next »

10
The indictment includes a photograph by Mr. Nauta that shows boxes spilling classified documents onto the floor of a storage room.

Page 15 of Trump Documents Indictment Color PDF document.

New York Times Analysis

« Previous
Next »

11
The existence of this recording came to public light this month. Mr. Trump claimed the document was written by Gen. Mark A. Milley, the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff.

Page 16 of Trump Documents Indictment Color PDF document.

New York Times Analysis

« Previous
Next »

12
In this recording, Mr. Trump acknowledged that he had a document that was still classified and was showing it to three other people who did not have security clearances and were not authorized to see it.

Page 17 of Trump Documents Indictment Color PDF document.

New York Times Analysis

« Previous
Next »

13
The indictment again uses Mr. Trump’s own words to condemn him.

14
Throughout the investigation, reporting suggested that investigators were examining the movement of boxes in and out of the storage room at Mar-a-Lago after Mr. Trump knew the government wanted the documents back.

Page 18 of Trump Documents Indictment Color PDF document.

Page 19 of Trump Documents Indictment Color PDF document.

Page 20 of Trump Documents Indictment Color PDF document.

New York Times Analysis

« Previous
Next »

15
The indictment accuses Mr. Nauta of lying to the F.B.I. about moving the boxes.

Page 21 of Trump Documents Indictment Color PDF document.

New York Times Analysis

« Previous
Next »

16
The details of this description of Mr. Nauta moving a box from the storage room, after a subpoena in May requested the return of the documents, most likely come from Mar-a-Lago security camera footage. Investigators also subpoenaed that footage.

17
Trump Attorney 1 remains unnamed in the document, but the designation appears to refer to Evan Corcoran, who played a key role in handling Mr. Trump’s responses to the government over its repeated requests for the return of the documents. Mr. Corcoran made a lengthy and detailed voice memo about his conversations with Mr. Trump. Mr. Smith fought a legal battle to obtain that material, and a federal judge ruled that the so-called crime-fraud exception to attorney-client privilege applied.

18
The indictment inserts this anecdote, apparently about personal emails on Mrs. Clinton’s private server that her lawyer had destroyed, without comment. The insinuation may be that Mr. Trump was implying, without directly asking, his lawyer to destroy classified documents he found problematic.

Page 22 of Trump Documents Indictment Color PDF document.

Page 23 of Trump Documents Indictment Color PDF document.

New York Times Analysis

« Previous
Next »

19
The special counsel appears to be connecting phone records and surveillance footage to show a link between Mr. Trump’s and Mr. Nauta’s actions.

Page 24 of Trump Documents Indictment Color PDF document.

New York Times Analysis

« Previous
Next »

20
The indictment suggests that Mr. Trump and Mr. Nauta hid boxes of documents from Mr. Corcoran, who would soon tell the Justice Department that there were no other files responsive to the subpoena — which was not true.

Page 25 of Trump Documents Indictment Color PDF document.

New York Times Analysis

« Previous
Next »

21
Here is another instance presented as Mr. Trump asking, without directly asking, for Mr. Corcoran to destroy classified documents rather than turn them over to the government.

Page 26 of Trump Documents Indictment Color PDF document.

New York Times Analysis

« Previous
Next »

22
The lawyer who signed a statement stating that a diligent search had been conducted and that all known classified information had been returned to the government was Christina Bobb, who was serving as the formal custodian of records for Mr. Trump’s office. The indictment makes clear she did not know the statements in the attestation were false.

Page 27 of Trump Documents Indictment Color PDF document.

New York Times Analysis

« Previous
Next »

Page 28 of Trump Documents Indictment Color PDF document.

New York Times Analysis

« Previous
Next »

24
Trump has been charged with violating a provision of the Espionage Act, a 1917 law that makes it a crime to hold onto secret government documents without authorization. This provision was enacted before the advent of the modern classification system, and it does not require prosecutors to prove that the secret documents had been deemed classified. Trump has claimed that he declassified everything that he took from the White House, although no credible evidence has emerged to support that claim. The penalty is up to 10 years per offense.

25
Only Mr. Trump – not Mr. Nauta – is charged with violations of the Espionage Act.

26
The indictment lists 31 documents, each of which is the subject of a separate count of Espionage Act violation.

Page 29 of Trump Documents Indictment Color PDF document.

Page 30 of Trump Documents Indictment Color PDF document.

Page 31 of Trump Documents Indictment Color PDF document.

Page 32 of Trump Documents Indictment Color PDF document.

Page 33 of Trump Documents Indictment Color PDF document.

Page 34 of Trump Documents Indictment Color PDF document.

New York Times Analysis

« Previous
Next »

27
Mr. Trump has been charged with violating a law that makes it a crime to corruptly impede an official proceeding. The penalty is up to 20 years per offense.

Page 35 of Trump Documents Indictment Color PDF document.

Page 36 of Trump Documents Indictment Color PDF document.

Page 37 of Trump Documents Indictment Color PDF document.

Page 38 of Trump Documents Indictment Color PDF document.

New York Times Analysis

« Previous
Next »

28
Mr. Trump has been charged with violating a law that makes it a crime to conceal records to obstruct an official effort. The penalty is up to 20 years per offense.

Page 39 of Trump Documents Indictment Color PDF document.

Page 40 of Trump Documents Indictment Color PDF document.

New York Times Analysis

« Previous

29
Mr. Trump and Mr. Nauta have each been charged with one count of violating a law that makes it a crime to issue false statements to federal investigators. Although Trump said little directly to law enforcement officials — instead communicating through his lawyers — people can be held liable for a crime if they induce other people to commit the action. The penalty is up to five years per offense.

30
Trump Attorney 3 appears to refer to Ms. Bobb. Mr. Trump is charged as the principal for the false statements made to the government in Ms. Bobb’s certification because he is accused of having induced them.

Page 41 of Trump Documents Indictment Color PDF document.

Page 42 of Trump Documents Indictment Color PDF document.

Page 43 of Trump Documents Indictment Color PDF document.

Page 44 of Trump Documents Indictment Color PDF document.

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *